Behavioural, Intellectual, Learning and Psychiatric challenges
- TAND stands for TSC Associated Neuropsychiatric Disorders
- TAND includes behaviour, intellectual disability, autism, learning difficulties and mental ill health
- The TAND checklist should be used annually to support screening for TAND
- More comprehensive assessment should be done at each developmental stage
- Management of TAND includes medicine and non-medicine based approaches
The impacts of TSC on behavior, learning and mental health are often the most difficult symptoms of TSC for families to cope with. It is important that families, carers, educators and health professionals are aware of these challenges; look for them in the TSC affected person at regular intervals; and implement appropriate strategies to deal with them.
The term TAND has been coined for these challenges. It stands for TSC-associated neuropsychiatric disorders. Other terms that can be used for these difficulties include “neurocognitive issues”, “neurobehavioural difficulties”, “learning issues”, “mental ill health”, “neuropsychiatric disorders”, and “cognitive and behavioural difficulties”. We know there can be stigma associated with some of these terms, however most often there are no alternative words to use.For this reason we have chosen to use the terms used by doctors and researchers in this area of TSC.
This Information page is divided into the following sections:
As with all TSA information pages, this information is not intended to, and it should not, constitute medical or other advice. Readers are warned not to take any action without first seeking medical advice. The best way to use this information is to bring it with you to your next appointment with your health professional.
- A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who specialises in the treatment of mental illness. Some psychiatrists will specialize in treating younger people, so may be called child and adolescent psychiatrists.
- A neuropsychiatrist is a medical doctor who specialises in the links between the brain and behaviour. They will usually be a psychiatrist before they take additional training to be a neuropsychiatrist.
- A developmental paediatrician is a medical doctor who has a special interest, training and experience in the development of children. This includes how they acquire knowledge and skills, and how they learn to behave and socialize. Developmental paediatricians tend to specialise in disorders of development such as autism, ADHD and intellectual disability.
- A clinical psychologist is a specially qualified psychologist who can provide assessment as well as treatment. There are many different types of psychologists and in Australia there are specific training requirements that need to be met before a person can call themselves a psychologist.
- Counsellors, social workers and therapists can have a range of different qualifications and experience.
- Special education teachers are specially trained to work with children who have special needs. They may be involved in creating individual plans, adapting teaching methods and equipment to suit the needs of the individual student.
Different professionals will describe different aspects of behaviour, learning and mental health differently. This can be confusing and people with TSC and their carers should ask for clarification if they are unsure what aspect of behavior, learning or mental health is being assessed or treated.
Researchers used to think that these difficulties were caused by a combination of:
- The number and position of tumours (tubers) in the brain
- The types of seizures, age of onset and whether the seizures can be controlled
However, as researchers have done more work, is has become clear that the molecular abnormalities caused by the TSC mutation can directly lead to learning, behavioural and mental health problems.
People with TSC who have infantile spasms and difficult to control epilepsy do seem to be at greater risk of developmental disorders including autism and intellectual disability. This is the reason that many neurologists will recommend an aggressive approach to seizure control, especially in young children.
Signs and Symptoms that make up TAND
The aim of understanding the different areas where a person with TSC may have difficulties is to identify the areas of strength and difficulties in each individual. This is done through regular screening and then assessment and testing. After these strengths and difficulties are identified the team of professionals can work with the family to work out what additional help may be needed to help the individual achieve their potential.
Different families will have different priorities and goals. Intervention should be individualised to meet the needs of both the person with TSC and their family.
It is important to remember that not every individual with TSC will have difficulties with every aspect of TAND. A diagnosis of Tuberous Sclerosis does mean that the individual is at an increased risk of difficulties in these areas at some point in their lifetime.
TAND can be understood by considering different levels or dimensions. These levels have been suggested by the Neuropsychiatry Panel at the 2012 International Consensus Conference. The levels are:behavioural; psychiatric; intellectual; academic; neuropsychological; and psychosocial.
The term “behavioural difficulties” refers to the problems that can be observed at home, at school or in a clinic. Some examples of difficult behaviours that are common in people with TSC are:
- Poor eye contact
- Repetitive and ritualistic behaviours
- Temper tantrums
- Sleep difficulties
- Depressed mood
- Extreme shyness
The behavioural level often represents a reason for referral by a GP or Paediatrician. A specialist team may then do a more comprehensive assessment.
Only some of these behavioural difficulties will be related to a specific disorder that can be diagnosed, such as an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or autism. These disorders are covered in more detail below. Diagnosis requires that a professional, such as a psychiatrist, developmental paediatrician or psychologist, use their expertise to assess the individual against the criteria for a specific psychiatric disorder.
Some of these behavioural difficulties are more common in people with TSC who also have an intellectual disability. For example, some surveys of TSC affected children and adolescents with an IQ in the normal range show that about half will have aggressive behaviours and about half will have sleep problems. TSC affected adults with an IQ in the normal range are at an increased risk of mood and anxiety disorders.
Sleep difficulties can include:
- insomnia, which is difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep;
- sleep apnea; and
- restless leg syndrome.
Most researchers have found people with TSC, and especially those with an intellectual disability, are at higher risk of sleep disturbances.
It can be very difficult to identify the cause and find treatments for sleep disturbances in people with TSC. This can be because they are having night time seizures or because of side effects of anti-epilepsy medication. When an individual has an intellectual disability and/or communication difficulties this can make it more difficult to understand the cause of sleep disturbances.
Sleep difficulties can sometimes be improved through behavioural management and and sometimes through medical treatment. Difficulties with sleep should be discussed by the individual with TSC (or their family member) and their health professional(s).
At this level behaviours that cause concern are evaluated in the context of the person’s age, developmental or intellectual level and other characteristics. Some people with TSC will meet the criteria for a specific disorder defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-5) or the International Classification of Diseases, tenth edition.
The most common psychiatric disorders experienced by people with TSC are:
- Autism spectrum disorders, experienced by between one quarter and one half of people with TSC
- Attention deficit and hyperactivity disorders, experienced by between one third and one half of people with TSC
- Anxiety and depressive disorders, experienced by between one third and over half of people with TSC.
Autism Spectrum Disorder
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a lifelong developmental disability characterised by marked and persistent difficulties in social communication and interaction together with restricted and repetitive interests and behaviours including sensory sensitivities.
The largest studies into rates of autism in children with TSC find that approximately 40-50% of children with TSC have an autism spectrum disorder. TSC is now considered to be the medical condition most strongly associated with autism, even more than fragile X or neurofibromatosis.
Diagnosis of autism includes assessment of two areas, in the context of the individual’s overall development and language skills:
- Social communications and interactions with others which can include difficulties in:
- social-emotional reciprocity, for example sharing of interests;
- nonverbal communication, for example eye contact; and
- developing, maintaining and understanding social relationships, for example playing, making friends or adjusting behaviours to different social environments.
- Restrictive or repetitive patterns of behaviour which can include:
- repetitive movements and use of language;
- ritual, routines and difficulties with transitions;
- interests which are unusual in their focus or intensity or interest in parts of objects eg wheels;
- over or under responsiveness to sensory input for example sounds, touch, light,
There is no one feature of autism that on its own can confirm or rule out autism. Autism spectrum disorder looks different in different individuals and especially varies with age, developmental skills and language skills. There is a wide spectrum of autism that ranges from very severe to very mild, this is the reason for the term autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
If a child with TSC demonstrates autistic behaviours it is important to seek a diagnostic evaluation. This is often the first step to receiving the appropriate services and support such as early intervention.
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is usually first diagnosed in childhood and can last into adulthood. Children with ADHD have trouble paying attention; have impulsive behaviours (may act without thinking about what the result will be); have difficulties with organising things; and in some cases are overly active.
Rates of ADHD in the general population are between 3 and 5%; in people with TSC the rate may be anywhere from 30% to 55%. Individuals who also have an intellectual disability may be more likely to also have ADHD.
The main groups of symptoms seen in ADHD are
- Inattention-related behaviours
- hyperactivity-related behaviours
- impulsivity-related behaviours.
The hyperactivity and impulsivity usually appear first, often beginning prior to the school age years. Inattention may not be recognized until primary school. The child with hyperactivity may fidget and squirm, can’t stay seated, runs when he or she should walk, is noisy, and is often described as constantly on the go. The impulsivity is seen as difficulty in waiting their turn, frequently interrupting others, and excessive talking even when expected to be quiet. The child with inattention finds it difficult to concentrate and is easily distracted, makes frequent careless errors, appears not to listen and struggles to complete work, is disorganized and therefore appears to procrastinate, and is forgetful and frequently loses books, homework or clothes.
As people with ADHD get older, the symptoms change in subtle ways. The teenager with hyperactivity and impulsivity feels restless and moves quickly from one task to the next, frequently failing to complete projects. Emotional disregulation, or mood swings, is another common symptom in older individuals with ADHD. While most people have some of these symptoms some of the time, the person with ADHD has many of these symptoms most of the time. In addition, these symptoms significantly impact their social life, education or work.
Many children with TSC may have behaviours that look like ADHD. These can be related to intellectual disability, epilepsy, enlarged SEGAs, sleep difficulties and other attention deficits. . It is therefore important that individuals with TSC who have attention-related problems should have a thorough assessment, so that ADHD or other problems can be diagnosed and treated.
Mood and Anxiety Disorders
Mood disorders include depression and bipolar disorder. Anxiety disorders include panic attacks, phobias and obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). Diagnosis involves symptoms that cause distress or impairment and persist for some time.
It is difficult to know the exact rates of these disorders in individuals with TSC. Most researchers agree that individuals with TSC, with and without an intellectual disability, are at increased risk of both mood and anxiety disorders.
Other Psychiatric Disorders
Beyond those discussed above, other psychiatric disorders include schizophrenia, other psychotic disorders, eating disorders and dementia. There is limited research into cases of these disorders in individuals with TSC and it is not clear whether people with TSC have an increased risk of these psychiatric disorders.
Psychotic disorders with hallucinations or delusions can be seen in association with epilepsy, particularly with temporal lobe seizures. If an individual with TSC experiences psychotic phenomenon, particularly visual hallucinatory phenomena, epileptic activity in the temporal lobe part of the brain should be investigated.
There are many different ways to evaluate intellectual ability. Different methods of testing will be suitable for different individuals and different ages.
The intellectual level is made up of both intellectual ability (measured by IQ type tests) and adaptive behaviours (such as self care, daily living skills and ability to communicate).
In TSC there is a very large range of intellectual abilities, from very high to extremely low. The graph illustrates this.
Studies of groups of people with TSC have shown that around 50% of individuals with TSC have an IQ score of less than 70, meaning that they have an intellectual disability, which may be mild, moderate or profound. Studies show that up to 30% of people with TSC have a profound impairment.
This research also suggests that around 50% of people with TSC do not have an intellectual disability.
Understanding an individual’s intellectual level is important to determine their likely support needs in daily life including educational support. It is also important when understanding behavioural difficulties.
Some research studies have also shown that even the most able individuals with TSC can have difficulties with executive skills. Executive skills are those related to how the brain’s “control centre” works and can include how the brain manages multi-tasking, planning and changing attention. Similar to other ways of assessing intellectual ability, there is not a predictable pattern of what types of executive skills an individual will have difficulties with. Again, this means that individual assessment is very important.
About developmental delay
Developmental delay is the term used when a young child is slower to reach milestones than other children. These milestones include talking and walking. Delay may occur in the way a child moves, communicates, or thinks and learns.
If the delay is ongoing, the child may be diagnosed with an intellectual disability. Specific developmental disabilities include autism and ADHD.
Developmental disability is a term used to describe disorders of development and includes intellectual disability, autism and ADHD. Signs of these disabilities start to appear early in development and impair individuals personal, social, academic or occupational functioning. You can read more about these developmental disabilities in other sections of this information page.
The academic level considers the various learning disorders that can impact how well a person does at school. Studies have suggested about a third of children with TSC that have normal or even superior intellectual ability have specific learning difficulties that require support. These students can be overlooked for support and may be considered lazy or stubborn.
This is why it is important to consider academic ability as a specific level and investigate any difficulties with reading, mathematics, written expression or other areas of education. There is no predictable pattern of challenges in individuals withTSC, so it is important to identify individual strengths and weaknesses.
This level refers to the different skills of the brain. These include:
- executive skills – which include the ability to plan steps in a complex task, to have multiple items in working memory and understanding a concept from multiple points of view.
- attentional skills – which include choosing what to pay attention to, paying attention for long periods of time and working on more than one task at the same time.
- language skills – which include difficulties understanding language (sometimes called a receptive language disorder) or using language (sometimes called an expressive language disorder).
- Memory skills – which include recognition and recall
- Visuospatial skills – which include challenges with navigation, drawing or constructing things.
These skills are usually evaluated by clinical psychologist using standardised measurement tools. Challenges in the above areas may correlate with behavioural challenges in real life.
This level refers to many different factors that influence a person’s quality of life. This includes:
- Family functioning
- Parental stress
- Relationship difficulties
All of these factors can be improved through various interventions and support.
There is research that shows high rates of psychosocial difficulties in families with TSC. However health professionals may not ask about this level.
Screening and Assessment for TAND
Screening and Assessment is important because it can lead to early detection and treatment. Each person with TSC should have an individual management plan developed with their medical team that uses the 2012 Consensus Conference guidelines as a starting point.
Understanding the behavioural, psychiatric, intellectual, academic, neuropsychological and psychosocial challenges experienced by someone with TSC is especially important because there is so much variation between different individuals with TSC. TAND may also arise later in life after many years of apparently “normal” functioning. By understanding the individual’s strengths and difficulties, the best treatment options can be determined.
The TAND checklist is a tool to guide a conversation between a health care professional and the individual with TSC or their caregiver. The checklist is a screening tool, not a diagnostic tool. Using the checklist well should create a priority list and an action plan for the next steps.
Action steps after using the TAND checklist may include:
- the individual, their parents or educators learning more about the disorder;
- conversations with school or education authorities to obtain an individual education plan;
- referral for specialist evaluation and/or treatment.
The Neuropsychiatry panel of the 2012 International TSC consensus conference recommend screening with the TAND checklist at least annually. Areas of concern should lead to next-step evaluations or interventions. Screening could be done with the doctor who co-ordinates the care of the person with TSC such as their GP, paediatrician or neurologist.
In addition, the panel also recommends comprehensive screening at key developmental stages. These are:
- Infancy (age 0-3);
- Pre-school years (age 3-6);
- Primary School years (age 6-9);
- Adolescence (age 12-16);
- Early adulthood (age 18-25);
and as required thereafter.
In addition, when there are changes in cognitive development or behaviour , a comprehensive assessment should be completed to identify and treat the underlying causes of neuropsychiatric change.
Assessment can involve many different health professionals who may work for different organisations. These might include doctors working in a hospital or private practice, therapists working in an independent centre or teachers working within the child’s school. Different health professionals will have different skills and tools for assessment.
In this session, Vanessa Sarkozy describes screening for developmental and behavioural challenges through a lifetime with TSC. Includes:
Understanding what screening is;
What screening is available to everyone within our health system;
What specific screening is recommended for individuals with TSC.
Management of TAND
Based on the results of individual assessment, an individual management plan should be developed. This plan should be developed in consultation with everyone on “the team”: the individual with TSC and their family along with the health and education professionals involved in their care.
This section describes some of the main options for managing TAND challenges in individuals with TSC. For many of the challenges experienced by a person with TSC the options for management are the same as in a person without TSC.
These might include:
- Education about the disorder(s): Learning more about the specific challenges facing the individual with TSC will usually be beneficial for all family members, carers and the person with TSC. This might include parents, siblings, grandparents, teachers, fellow students, colleagues and respite carers.
- Managing Behaviours: interventions may be particularly effective for very challenging behaviours such as self-injury, aggression and sleep problems. With expert support, even severely challenging behaviours can be reduced, managed or shaped into more appropriate behaviour. Because early intervention is most effective, behaviour management should be instituted early even for minor behavioural challenges.
- Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT): This approach can help an individual identify their own unhelpful behaviours and thoughts and find ways of handling them differently.
- Coaching Techniques: A coach can work with the individual to identify areas of weakness and then work on these as skills to develop. This is a very practical approach that may be helpful to a broad range of people and challenges.
- Psychodynamic therapies: This approach involves a therapist helping a person reflect on their unconscious thought processes that lead to conflict. Options include psychotherapy, family therapy, relationship therapy.
- Autism spectrum disorder management: There are many different strategies that may help to create a learning and home environment that is “autism-friendly”. This might include clear and simple communication, consistent routines and visualized schedules. There are other interventions specifically designed for ASD. It is important to understand that these interventions may have varying amount of evidence on whether they work. Autism organisations can provide more information.
Medication can have a role to play in treating the TAND challenges in individuals with TSC. It is important to consider how any medication will impact organs of the body that may also be affected by TSC or under stress due to anti-epilepsy medication, such as the heart, kidneys and liver.
It may be useful to consider medication to treat:
- Severe ADHD
- Depression and Anxiety disorders
- Sleep disorders
- Challenging behaviours
Medicines should always be used in combination with other behavioural, educational and other strategies, never on their own.
There is some evidence from clinical trials and research in animal models that mTOR inhibitor medications may have a positive impact on behaviour and learning. This research is still in progress and it will be some time before it is known whether these medicines should be prescribed to treat these difficulties.
Individuals with TSC with normal or high intelligence are particularly at risk of struggling in a classroom. This is because they may have specific area of weaknesses that may be “invisible” to the untrained eye. These may include difficulties with attention or dual tasking. This is another way that individual assessment can help.
About this article
Last updated 20th April 2015
Prepared by Clare Stuart, Tuberous Sclerosis Australia
2015 version reviewed by Dr Vanessa Sarkozy, Developmental Paediatrician, Sydney Children’s Hospital Network, Australia
2012 version reviewed by Prof Petrus de Vries, Sue Struengmann Professor of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, University of Cape Town, South Africa
Family review provided by Sue Williamson and Fiona Crocker.
- de Vries, P.J., et al., Tuberous sclerosis associated neuropsychiatric disorders (TAND) and the TAND Checklist. Pediatr Neurol, 2015. 52(1): p. 25-35.
- Leclezio, L., et al., Pilot validation of the tuberous sclerosis-associated neuropsychiatric disorders (TAND) checklist. Pediatr Neurol, 2015. 52(1): p. 16-24.
- Kwiatkowski D.J., Whittemore V.H. & Thiele E.A. (2010) Tuberous Sclerosis Complex: Genes, Clinical Features, and Therapeutics. Weinheim: Wiley-Blackwell
- Guidelines For The Assessment Of Cognitive And Behavioral Issues In TSC, Tuberous Sclerosis Alliance, viewed 10 May 2012, http://tsalliance.org/pages.aspx?content=589
- Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder And Tuberous Sclerosis Complex , Tuberous Sclerosis Alliance, viewed 10 May 2012, http://tsalliance.org/pages.aspx?content=582
- TSC and Autism Spectrum Disorders, Tuberous Sclerosis Alliance, viewed 10 May 2012, http://tsalliance.org/pages.aspx?content=604